What Russia Wants in Ukraine

Foto ilustracyjneFoto ilustracyjne
Źródło zdjęć: © Licencjodawca | Foto: Stock Adobe, Tomasz Warszewski

How did the crisis unfold? One week into the largest military mobilisation in Europe since the Second World War, this guide explains how the crisis reached this point and what is at stake for Russia, the United States and NATO.

It resembled a scene from the Cold War, a dangerous episode from a bygone era. An unpredictable Russian leader was massing troops and tanks on a neighbour's border. There were fears of a bloody conflagration sweeping from east to west.

Then the Cold War turned hot: Vladimir Putin ordered Russian troops to attack Ukraine. The repercussions were immediate and far-reaching.

In the days leading up to the invasion, as Russian forces reached an estimated strength of 190,000 and the United States warned in increasingly ominous terms that a military attack appeared imminent, Putin maintained that he was open to diplomacy. European leaders worked desperately to persuade the Kremlin to stand down.

Then, on 24 February, the Russian president addressed his nation and announced the start of a "special military operation" in Ukraine.

The largest mobilisation of forces in Europe since 1945 was now under way, as Ukrainian soldiers and civilian resistance fighters fought to repel a Russian assault on multiple fronts.

Talks between Russian and Ukrainian delegations began on Monday in Belarus, a close ally of Moscow, but there was more movement on the battlefield than at the negotiating table. A 17-mile Russian convoy was reported to be advancing towards Kyiv. In a chilling escalation, a barrage of Russian rockets struck a residential district of Kharkiv, Ukraine's second-largest city, killing at least nine civilians and wounding dozens.

Independent observers speculated that Putin, frustrated by his forces' unexpectedly slow progress despite their considerable numerical advantage, may have grown impatient as they encountered strong resistance from both Ukrainian soldiers and civilians. He may therefore have decided to intensify the bombardment, which observers warned could cause more civilian casualties.

The number of refugees who had fled the country exceeded half a million. Putin appeared intent on capturing Kyiv, overthrowing Ukraine's democratically elected government and pulling the country into Russia's orbit.

The invasion threatened to destabilise an already volatile post-Soviet region, with serious consequences for the security architecture that had governed Europe since the 1990s. Putin had long lamented the loss of Ukraine and other republics after the collapse of the Soviet Union. His broader aim may have been to weaken NATO, the military alliance that helped contain the Soviets. Before the invasion, Russia set out a list of far-reaching demands to reshape that structure, all rejected by NATO and the United States.

What Lies Behind the Crisis in Ukraine

After the Soviet Union collapsed, NATO expanded eastwards, eventually taking in most European countries that had been in the communist sphere. The Baltic republics of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia, once part of the Soviet Union, joined NATO, as did Poland, Romania and others.

As a result, NATO moved hundreds of miles closer to Moscow and came to share a border with Russia. In 2008, the alliance said it planned to admit Ukraine one day, although that remained a distant prospect.

Putin described the Soviet collapse as a catastrophe that deprived Russia of its rightful place among the world's great powers and left it at the mercy of a predatory West. He spent his 22 years in power rebuilding Russia's military and reasserting its geopolitical influence.

The Russian president called NATO expansion threatening and viewed the prospect of Ukraine joining the alliance as a serious danger to his country. As Russia became more assertive and militarily stronger, his complaints about NATO sharpened. He repeatedly raised the spectre of US ballistic missiles and combat forces in Ukraine, although US, Ukrainian and NATO officials said none were there.

Putin also insisted that Ukraine and Belarus were fundamentally parts of Russia, culturally and historically. He exerted considerable influence over Belarus, and talks about some form of union with Russia had continued for years.

East-West relations deteriorated sharply in early 2014, however, when mass protests in Ukraine ousted a president closely allied with Putin. Russia swiftly invaded and annexed Crimea, part of Ukraine. Moscow also fomented a separatist uprising that seized control of part of Ukraine's Donbas region, in a war that was still continuing and had killed more than 13,000 people.

What Putin Wants

Putin appeared intent on turning the clock back more than 30 years by establishing a broad, Russian-dominated security zone reminiscent of Moscow's authority in the Soviet era. Now 69 and probably nearing the end of his political career, he clearly wanted to draw Ukraine, a country of 44 million people, back into Russia's sphere of influence.

In December, Russia presented NATO and the United States with a set of written demands that it said were necessary to guarantee its security. Chief among them were assurances that Ukraine would never join NATO, that NATO would withdraw forces from Eastern European countries that had already joined the alliance, and that a 2015 ceasefire agreement in Ukraine would be implemented, although Moscow and Kyiv sharply disagreed over what that would entail.

The West rejected the main demands outright, while offering to discuss other concerns and threatening sanctions. Moscow's aggressive posture also fuelled Ukrainian nationalism, and citizen militias prepared for a prolonged guerrilla campaign in the event of Russian occupation.

Putin's timing may also have been connected to the transition from President Donald J. Trump, who was particularly friendly towards him and dismissive of NATO, to President Biden, who was committed to the alliance and wary of the Kremlin.

He may also have wanted to rally nationalists at home by focusing on an external threat, as he had done before. Putin had crushed domestic challenges to his rule, but the previous year, as the economy worsened and the pandemic raged, opposition groups staged some of the largest anti-Putin protests in years. Since the invasion began, thousands of Russians had taken to the streets, some at great personal risk, to protest against the war.

How the United States Is Responding

In early December, President Biden made clear that his administration was not considering sending troops to fight for Ukraine, partly because Ukraine was not a NATO member and was therefore not covered by the alliance's collective-defence commitment.

Instead, the United States sent anti-tank and anti-aircraft weapons to Ukraine, increased the US military presence in NATO countries bordering Russia and ordered an additional 7,000 troops to Europe. The Pentagon also ordered an armoured brigade to deploy to Germany to reassure anxious NATO allies in Eastern Europe. Administration officials also warned that the United States could support a Ukrainian insurgency.

The most powerful weapon, however, was financial.

Before the invasion, Biden threatened Putin with "economic consequences he had never seen". He then began to impose them. Vowing to make Putin a "pariah", Biden announced tough new sanctions intended to cut Russia's largest banks and some oligarchs off from much of the global financial system and prevent the country from importing US technology crucial to its defence, aerospace and maritime industries. The administration also sanctioned the company behind the gas pipeline linking Russia and Germany.

Biden also said the United States had frozen trillions of dollars in Russian assets, including funds controlled by Russian elites and their families, forcing them to pay for what the US president called a "premeditated attack" on a free nation in Europe.

Western governments also promised to freeze assets belonging to Putin, although little was known about what he owned or where those assets might be held.

The Biden administration could also impose sanctions that might deprive Russians of their cherished next-generation phones, laptops and other gadgets.

What Is at Stake for Europe

At stake for Europe was the security architecture that had helped preserve peace on the continent since the Second World War. Europeans were initially divided over how to respond to different forms of Russian aggression, and the conflict exposed divisions within the European Union and NATO. Outrage over Putin's aggression, however, helped strengthen a united front, and the EU unveiled penalties that it described as unprecedented for the bloc in scale and reach.

Europe had important trade ties with Russia and stood to lose far more from sanctions than the United States. It also depended on Russian gas supplies, a vulnerability Putin had exploited in previous disputes.

Europe lost an invaluable interlocutor with Moscow when Chancellor Angela Merkel left office. Having grown up in East Germany, she spoke fluent Russian and had developed a good working relationship with the Russian president. Her successor, Olaf Scholz, tried to assume a leadership role in a crisis that intensified soon after his election. He halted certification of Nord Stream 2, a gas pipeline that would have linked Germany and Russia, in one of the West's strongest steps to punish the Kremlin up to that point.

Selected for you